You’re standing at the cashier point in your favourite grocery store, ready to pay for your purchases. As you reach for your card, you pause for a moment, should you use your credit card or debit card? Which one is better for everyday purchases like groceries, dining, online shopping, and pay?
This is a common dilemma for many. Whether you’re using cash or plastic, deciding between a credit card and a debit card can be tricky. While both get the job done when it comes to shopping or paying bills, there are key differences that can influence your choice.
When you swipe your debit card, the funds are usually drawn from your checking account or another linked account on the same day.
On the other hand, using a credit card means borrowing money from the credit card issuer, which you can either pay off monthly or carry a balance with interest. But these are just some differences that make these two types of cards more distinct than they might seem.
In this blog post, we will highlight the differences between credit cards and debit cards, comparing their pros and cons to help you decide which is best for your situation.
Credit Cards Vs Debit Cards: A Quick Glance
Here is a quick comparison between credit cards and debit cards in Canada:
Credit Card | Debit Card |
With credit cards, you borrow money from the credit issuer and you pay it back later, often with interest if not paid in full by the due date. | With debit cards, you get direct access to funds from your bank account and the money is withdrawn immediately. |
Interest is charged on unpaid balances or cash advances, often at high rates (e.g., 20% or more). No interest if you pay the balance in full monthly. | No interest charges since you're spending your own money. |
Often offers rewards, cashback, points, and travel perks, which can add value if used responsibly. | Debit cards offer few or no rewards, though some banks offer minimal perks (like small cashback). |
Card issuers set credit limits based on your credit score, income, and history. As you build credit, you may get higher limits. | Debit cards are limited to the balance available in your checking account; no borrowing allowed beyond that unless you have overdraft protection. |
Many credit cards offer fraud protection, zero-liability coverage for unauthorized purchases, and chargeback options for disputes. | Some banks offer fraud protection on debit cards, but it’s generally less extensive than credit. |
Useful for emergencies as it allows for delayed payment, so you can make purchases even if you’re short on funds. | Debit cards require that funds be immediately available and it is ideal for budgeting. |
The risk of overspending is higher, due to the ‘buy now, pay later’ nature of credit. | The risk of overspending is lower, as it relies only on funds in your account. |
Credit cards charge fees including annual fees, late fees, cash advance fees, and foreign transaction fees. | Debit cards generally have no fees for regular transactions, though some banks charge monthly account fees or overdraft fees if your account goes negative. |
Pros of Using Credit Cards
Credit cards offer several benefits, but they also come with risks. Here’s a breakdown of the advantages and disadvantages of using them:
- Build Credit History: Using a credit card responsibly helps build your credit history. On-time payments and keeping your card balances low compared to your credit limit can improve your credit score. However, late payments or overspending can harm it, as all activity is recorded on your credit report.
- Warranty and Purchase Protections: Some credit cards offer extended warranties or additional insurance on purchases. For example, if a product breaks after the manufacturer’s warranty ends, your credit card might cover repairs or replacement. Many cards also include purchase protection for stolen or lost items and price protection if you find the same item cheaper elsewhere.
- Fraud Protection: If your credit card is lost or stolen, your liability is limited to $50 as long as you report it promptly. Debit cards also offer protection, but only if the loss is reported within 48 hours. After that, liability can increase to $500 or more.
Cons of Using Credit Cards
- Risk of Debt: With credit cards, you’re spending borrowed money that must be repaid with interest. If you carry a balance or miss payments, debt can quickly add up, making it hard to manage monthly bills.
- Impact on Credit Score: While responsible use boosts your credit score, misusing credit cards can hurt it. Late payments, maxed-out cards, closing old accounts, or frequently applying for new credit can lower your score.
- Interest and Fees: Credit cards charge interest on balances carried over from month to month. Additionally, you may face various fees, such as annual fees, foreign transaction fees, or late payment penalties. Cards with the best rewards programs often come with higher fees, so it’s essential to weigh the benefits against the costs.
Best Time To Use Your Credit Card
Credit cards are a useful tool if you’re looking to build a credit history or improve your credit score. If you trust yourself to spend responsibly and make on-time payments, using a credit card consistently can boost your credit and help you qualify for loans with favourable terms down the road.
Additionally, credit cards offer strong fraud protection, which is particularly valuable when shopping online or making high-value purchases.
However, poor credit card management can lead to financial stress. Although credit cards allow you to finance large purchases and pay them off over time, it’s best to avoid regularly carrying a balance.
By paying your credit card bill in full and on time each month, you can avoid accumulating interest charges and additional fees.
Pros of Using Debit Cards
- Avoiding Debt: Debit cards use the money you already have, so there’s no risk of accumulating debt or paying high-interest charges. For those who tend to overspend with credit, debit cards can help you stick to your budget and avoid impulsive purchases.
- Fraud Protections: Modern debit cards, especially those from Visa or Mastercard, now offer fraud protections similar to credit cards. However, you must report any unauthorized transactions quickly to minimize liability. If fraud isn’t reported in time, you could be held responsible for losses. Since debit cards pull money directly from your account, unauthorized purchases can lead to overdrafts or empty your account—unlike credit cards, where payments happen later.
- No Annual Fees: Debit cards don’t charge annual fees. Plus, withdrawing cash from your bank’s ATMs is free, unlike credit cards, which charge cash advance fees and start accruing interest immediately. However, keep in mind that maintaining your checking account may come with its own fees.
Cons of Using Debit Cards
- No Rewards: Unless tied to a rewards checking account, debit cards don’t earn points, miles, or cashback on purchases. By not using a credit card, you could miss out on savings from redeeming rewards.
- Doesn’t Build Credit: Using a debit card doesn’t contribute to building your credit history because it doesn’t involve borrowing money. A strong credit history can make it easier to secure loans, reduce security deposits on rentals, and access better financial opportunities. Debit cards don’t help with that.
- Potential Fees: While debit cards lack annual fees, checking accounts may include costs like monthly maintenance fees, overdraft fees (if you overspend), returned-item fees (for declined payments), and foreign ATM fees (for out-of-network withdrawals).
Best Time To Use Your Debit Card
Debit cards work well for everyday purchases like lunch at the office or grabbing groceries on the way home. For these smaller, frequent expenses, debit cards allow you to track your spending easily and make sure you have enough money in your checking account to cover each transaction.
Since a debit card only allows you to spend the money already in your account, it can help you develop strong spending habits without the risk of overspending.
If carrying a credit card balance is a temptation for overspending, using a debit card can offer more control and a greater sense of accountability. Debit cards are also convenient for cash access, allowing you to withdraw money directly from your account or get cash back during a transaction when ATMs aren’t available.
RECOMMENDED READINGS:
